Last year, I received a birthday gift from Sephora, a lipstick and a black eyeliner from Marc Jacobs. A very nice color lipstick but it was the eyeliner that surprised me. I don't like to use an eyeliner because it just doesn't stay pretty very long on my eyelids. But this Marc Jacobs Gel Eye Crayon is the first eyeliner that doesn't smudge. The eyeliner is perfect for my waterline, better said my upper waterline, because then I just seem to have a very thin line of eyeliner. I received the eyeliner in the color black with a satin finish. Now ...